I just read a blog post that said Autistics need to get their stuff together. I'm assuming it means about the stimming and stuff, and the fact that we seem not to understand emotions. Well, this is what I have to say on the topic: both our kinds need to get it together. You can't empathize with anyone outside your non-Autistic branch of the human family, and the people in my area have the most difficulty making themselves understood.
In fact, one person had said, "I do not hold such view. Stimming and destructive behavior are not communication. An autistic does not communicate with anyone this way, not even with another autistic. These form a pathological behavior which has a neurological underpinning and it doesn't form a medium of information exchange - hence, no communication."
In reply, I say, "Yes, but how do you vocalize? By magic? Without nerves? Yelling when you drop a book on your toe is no better than hand flapping in reply. How do bees communicate? Motion. So those arm flappers that get the publisher's clearing house award have as much meaning as an autistic to you? They are like the Rosetta Stone. The "Greek" is written on their posture, their face, and coming out their mouths. It is "Greek" to us. But for the sake of the metaphor, your kind are like the linguists in the story. The Ancient Egyptian are the things their arms are doing. Our nonverbals speak it fluently. You speak and understand it to a negative percentage. You're only slightly capable with your own kind. I hate it. How can you claim any degree of empathy if you still get into misunderstandings and arguments with your own kind!
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
About Me
- De Chao
- Live Long and Prosper! I am an eccentric. I like Jewish/Hebrew music, focusing on whatever special interests I have, especially if it concerns my friends. Quintessentially, I love my gifts from God. I dislike it when people dislike the lives of their own children, and torture them in the name of training and treatment. My dreams for the future are to become a Professor, writer, wife and mum. May the Force be with you!
Blog Archive
-
▼
2009
(98)
-
▼
October
(11)
- Some Non-Autistics are just plain hypocritical abo...
- This would have been an open letter to John Best, ...
- Ten Warning Signs of "Normality"
- Jokes for British People
- How to spread awareness
- Why Should Christians Care About Neurodiversity?
- Countdown to the Dawn Treader!
- "to restrict or narrow conditions under which inte...
- Eagle
- Who am I?
- Tantrums
-
▼
October
(11)
How can anyone claim a degree of empathy, indeed?
ReplyDeleteLove the comparisons with Greeks and Egyptians (the ancient ones).
The way I figure it, empathy couldn't even be scientifically testable. Empathy would have to be figuring out everything a person's thinking (or be within eighty eight percent of it, no misconceptions that change more than two percent of the idea, and you'd have to be completely accurate otherwise), and have felt what you know they've felt before. Crazy, no? But NTs do argue a lot.
ReplyDeleteIt's non-falsifiable, according to Popper.
ReplyDeleteI have empathy when I feel what they've felt before, but not the figuring out of their thinking. What they think is what they think, even if I should have thought something similar.